fomapan 400 vs hp5

Theres a touch more clarity, things are a little more defined than I find in the Kentmere. Kodak Tri-X 400 is a classic, and was the first film I started shooting with back in college. Exposure: 1/500 @ F5.6 (Y2 filter and rubber lens hood) Film: Fomapan 200 Creative dev. I wasnt expecting to prefer Fomapan overexposed, but I cant argue with the results. Also, I will not be doing anything I consider to be "my work." Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. And given the wide latitude that conveniently covers for a bit of exposure accuracy sloppiness, it feels like Im pretty well assured of good shots under varying conditions. Im still not sure about Kentmere 400. In my experience it really shines one stop from box, at EI200. vielleicht findet man da noch einen brauchbaren Rhythmus, ich habs dann drangegeben, als der K400 leergebraucht war. Although I wouldnt if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[580,400],'35mmc_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_10',180,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-35mmc_com-medrectangle-3-0'); I think this experience definitely demonstrated to me the way that box speed is subjective. Thanks Peter!I deliberately chose frames with similar tones so it would be a bit trickier.The one of the left is the Fomapan. ? Definitely a characterful film with quirks, and requiring experimentation before a user can be comfortable with what it offers. Bringt der APX 400 tatschlich 640 ASA bei Rodinal? Aber Rodinal mit ISO 400 geht doch, finde ich. Learn how your comment data is processed. These images show how much information is available in these highlights when metered and exposed dead-on, as well as what detail is retained within the shadows and what is lost. I only used three cassettes of Fomapan 400 in 135 because shot outside I found it quite grainyhowever shots I made indoors under low light in a church and a museum looked really good. I want to try the films out myself now. Find out more about 35mmc here. And believe me, they are crummy. So by exposing for the shadows, youre basically over exposing it 2-3 stops and thus placing the shadows off the toe and onto the linear part of the film curve? Filling the Gap Photography & Mental Health. I bought some and tried it and it worked. I like the old-fashioned look of Foma films, here Fomapan 200 Creative: Camera: Mamiya C330 Professional. All our Contributors have an ad-free experience for life.Sign uphere. Much brighter on the figure, much darker on areas not touched by light. Warum den AGFA-Rhythmus? It has more highlight bleed and halation than Kentmere, but this is rarely overwhelming in the way it may be on something like Cinestill 800t. I buy all of my film from Analogue Wonderland. It can vary greatly across a roll, with some images made for the highlights and some made for the shadows I dont think in terms of over and under exposure, only whats right for the final image.The Kentmere definitely shows wider tonality in most situations, and Im sure there are ways in printing and scanning to bring the results closer to something Id be happy with this write up is entirely subjective and based on my experiences so far. The same can be said for HP5 Plus. Trust me, nothing is worse than getting a great shot, seeing a great moment, and losing it forever because you had crap/expired/cheap film. These are nice, there is something about the crappy anti halation layer film when you pull it and blow the highlights a bit, it turns the glowiness up to 11.How do you prevent scratches, Simon? Shooting with Fomapan is a bit like traveling in the past. Id also highly recommend Kentmere 100, which I didnt test here but still make use of quite often. Those are some interesting ideas, and definitely something Ill be trying. Having now revisited it with my more advanced skillset Im happy with the look it can offer, and have a better []. Im not an authority on development my interest lies in the shooting experience, and for me this ends when the shutter is pressed. Warum hast den denn den Agfa Kipp verwendet, denn es ist ja vermutlich ein Ilford Film. Another suggestion would be to shoot Kentmere 400 at box speed, but through a yellow or orange filter to boost the contrast. Thanks for experimenting with this film so the rest of us can just go straight to the EI that gave you these great results! HP5 habe ich unter diesem Handelsnamen nie verwendet, aber als Kentmere400 wird wohl eine recht hnliche Emulsion angeboten. But HP5 Plus offers something different than Tri-X - stronger Honestly, if money is that big an object or is the sole criteria, then just steal TMY2 or TriX. weil rodinal von AGFA ist. in Atomal49 1+2 kam er noch differentierter und mit schnen Grauwerten. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. Id leave the sharpening to Photoshop. for Accessibility for blind people who use screen readers; Press?? Rollei retro 400s/FX-39ii development time, Portra 400 35mm in-stock at Free Style (USA). Its cheaper than tri-x and hp5+. If you want some quality on iso 1600 with a iso 400 film use the HP5+ or films like delta 3200 or Tmax 3200 on iso 1600. als der Silvermax darin ebenso mit guten Ergebnissen entwickeln lassen. 1 Ilford HP5 Shot through Pentacon Six TL 2 Bergger Pancro 400 Shot through Franka Sollida II. An update here. You cant throw any developer at Fomapan 400 and expect pleasing results. Except that if things go wrong then the monetary loss is greater with the more expensive film. Also scanner brand and model name please. All negatives were scanned on a Nikon D810 with the 60mm f/2.8 AF-S macro lens and a Nikon ES-2 adapter, which is a massive leap forward in quality from the V600 I used when I first started shooting film. There are several 5 Frames With articles Ive written here on 35mmc which look at some of the results from these different exposure combinations with Fomapan 400. The high contrast results really lent a wonderful aesthetic to those images, and Im glad I didnt choose to take Kentmere. Re: Fomapan 100, 200 and 400. Fomapan 400 @ 1600 Fomapan 400 @ 1600 This roll of Fomapan 400 was exposed EI1600 and developed at a +2 stop push. Fomapan 400, exposed for the wall/tent light. The fact that this experimentation was necessary with Fomapan but not with the Kentmere is quite damning in my opinion. because theyre reliable and inexpensive. However I think there are some quite distinguished features to the grains of these films that should remain constant regardless of the technique used. When it comes to Fomapan film, results and opinions are mixed. In any case, most of my enjoyment comes from the process, not my crummy images. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. But dont limit yourself to those; it also sings in Kodak D-23. The Professional's Source Since 1973 Als Entwickler D76 zu nehmen ist zweifelsohne eine gute Wahl, doch gehrt der Entwickler und der Platzverbrauch der Flaschen fr die Stammlsung in meinem Laborbestand wohl bald der Vergangenheit an. I decided to give Fomapan 400 a try after discovering that it is exactly the same price as Kentmere 400. Id say its Kentmere on the left and Fomapan on the right. M3+50er Elmar auf Silvermax. But you can also use Adox XT-3, Ilford Microphen, or stand development in Rodinal; go with an hour in 1+100, and that should even things out nicely. However due to my slow shooting style I didnt have these images ready in any kind of timeframe that would make sense, and have since shot a number of rolls of both, which has given me a little more to talk about. Character is quite a subjective measurement, and different people will assess different qualities when discussing it. I just dont shoot enough film to make the price per roll very relevant, but I think youd be hard pressed to find a B&W film in this price range that performs this well. I love Kentmete films for when I need to test a camera, lens, etc. du hast freie Wahl: - mit Rodinal 1+50 fr gute Empfindlichkeitsausnutzung bis 640 ASA, Schrfe und normale Kontraste, (aber mitunter lange Entwicklugszeiten, die beim Agfakipprhythmus anstrengend werden), - mit Rodinal 1+100 fr hnlich gute Ergebnisse bei weiger Bewegungsarbeit fr den Arm in der (semi-)Standentwicklungund sparsamerer Ausnutzung der chemie, - mit Atomal49 fr schne Grauwerte aber nur bis 320 ASA und etwas weniger scharf, dafr weicheres Korn, - mit D76 fr Nennempfindlichkeit und etwas krzere Entwicklugnszeiten, - mit Rodinal 1+25 um den 60er-Jahre Zeitungsfoto-vintagelook mit ordentlich Korn und knackigen Kontrasten wiederzubeleben. Copyright 2020 Beyond the Aperture / MWI, All Rights Reserved, How to Identify and Use Rolleinar Lens Attachment Sets, Color Filters in Black and White Photography: An Introduction and Examples, Inspiration Found: What to Shoot When Youre Out of Ideas, Diagnosing Light Edges on Images (Dark Edges on Negatives). If Fomas QC were that good, then Id rather have the Foma. If excessive grain is not disturbing you for the Fomapan 400 you can go for Rodinal. To learn more, check-out the About page, or read News for the latest. Processed in Legacy Pro L-110 (HC110 knock off) 1:40 from concentrate, 12 min at 19 deg. Ill tweak things in time and see if anything can be made to work better for me, but for now these are my opinions on each emulsion! If everything goes well I will save up some pennies for an Olympus Pen FT. The look of Kentemere reminds me of those surveillance films, or JHC400, so maybe that would be the most direct comparison. Some people maintain that it has that vintage TriX feel from the 60s. Let me start by tell you Im surprised at the cost of film in the UK. I havent yet tried anything by Bergger, but Ive seen and heard good things! I ask because my 30.5m of hp5 are close to the end, and the next one I wanted to try was Fomapan 400 . ehrlich gesagt habe ich keine Ahnung. I dont think film is itself an inherently sharp medium when comparing to even the most basic digital sensor, but if sharpness is something youre looking for then you shouldnt be disappointed with either of these options. Thanks Matthias! But for some, $20 is a big deal. Lines are clean, and micro-contrast is maintained. Lets face it: Shooting film is not exactly the cheapest of all possible endeavors. auch in D76 ist das von mir erzielte Ergebnis des Foma400 immer eher zweifelhaft gewesen. If youre a fan of a particular era of films and love that high-speed crunch and grain that youd find in a 1970s roll of Kodak Tri-X and are okay with a bit of speed loss or an increase of grain plus a bit of soft mush and a mid-to-low contrast than Fomapan 400 might be a film to try. The images made with that extra stop of light were enough to allow me to settle for [], [] The images above all felt under exposed. Kentmere 400, exposed for the interior of the car. (Never shot Ilford) I am definitely going to try Kentmere. First, a quick bit about the technical specs behind this comparison. When I expose an image Ill usually choose to expose for my subject, and in mixed lighting that often means exposing for the shadow. Contribute to 35mmc for an Ad-Free Experience-, Fuji C200 Review A short note on my Enduring Love for this film By Phil Stefans, Kodak Portra 400 My First Roll by Simon King, Fuji Pro 400H & Kodak Portra 400 Quest For Colour By Aukje, NOSSAFLEX - An organising tool for film photography - Launches on Kickstarter, The Beauty of Basic: Life with One Lens - By Will Mordell, Camera, Lens, Film and Peripheral Kit Reviews. I thought it would be interesting to discuss the two, and make a few comparisons where appropriate in order to help guide people towards making a choice between perhaps the most popular budget black and white films on the market.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[728,90],'35mmc_com-box-3','ezslot_1',179,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-35mmc_com-box-3-0'); Ill be talking about the 400 variations of both as 400 speed films offer me the most diverse uses for general purpose, all-light shooting. It is a true 400 ISO film. Lastly, I converted the file to 16-bit Grayscale and added a curves layer to set the white/black points in Photoshop. Have you tried Bergger pancro 400? I no longer have to cross my fingers hoping that the negatives will come out. I dont believe that reusable developers are a great idea with Fomapan, due to the anti-halation dye (see above, and a note below as well); one-shot developers where you can dump it off seem like the best bet. You can see the loss of highlight at the top of the frame, but there are more shades of grey that are maintained. I am not sure that I agree with you on the contrast. Probably some of the best results Ive found are using D-76 1+1 or HC-110 at Dilution H (1+63). However I still wanted to see whether Fomapan 400 could work for me in any other use cases, and so shot this roll at EI200, one stop overexposed consistently. . 21 Grad, 19 Minuten AGFA in R1+50 haben bei mir 640 ASA gebracht. Out of all the films I tested, I felt Tri-X had the best balance of contrast overall. Is that the new Jane Bond? 35mmc is a blog authored, edited and published by Hamish Gill featuring daily articles submitted by readers. I mentioned in the Workflow section that the bulk of work shown was in either DDX or Fujifilm chemistry. leider habe ich beim K400 aber in der standentwicklung nie die Wlkchen in den Griff gekriegt- die Entwicklung wurde immer fleckig und ungleichmig, weil ja die Bewegung fehlte. Ich mchte einen klassischen Film verwenden, die Tmax und Deltas fallen also raus. Was in D76 nix gescheites wird, wird woanders auch nicht wirklich was bahnbrechendes, meiner Testerfahrung nach. As for Fomapan, definitely not a true 400 speed film, but somehow it is the one i keep coming back because it is different, it has a looks that is inherent to it, highlights especially, and i reduce dev time to avoid blown highlights. Im Schrank lagern noch zwei ungeffnete Pulverstze fr D 76 bzw. That stuff came in handy as I dabbled in that artsy stuff. . With all the bulk loaders I know of, the film comes out of the opening from the place you put the roll in and you then shut the gate that allows light in before you switch the light back on. I think both films perform fantastically at rendering sharpness into their frames. I have been using Kentmere 400 for years now, primarily because its comes in at the cheaper (cheapest?) Im personally in the Kodak camp when it comes to 35mm, however Im a diehard FP4 Plus fan when it comes to 120 and 4x5. TLDR: Differences are minimal, both are cheap, Kentmere very very slightly better. Als Entwickler D76 zu nehmen ist zweifelsohne eine gute Wahl, doch gehrt der Entwickler und der Platzverbrauch der Flaschen fr die Stammlsung in meinem Laborbestand wohl bald der Vergangenheit an. C. Continuous gentle rocking face up (single neg) in a tray. HP5 Plus. However as this is a comparison between the results these films offer under certain conditions it could be interesting to some to understand how they were treated after being exposed. It also dries flat so picking it up is a little trickier. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Personally though, as someone who accepts, even likes grain, and isnt averse to the look that youll get out of both of these films in Rodinol I am definitely thinking that the Fomapan offering will get a few more chances to impress. I started off with HC-110 but found the dilutions impractical for most film I shot. Fomapan 400 can also be used for street work in dull conditions or in areas where you want to show off a bit more crunch to go with urban decay. Fibonawak 8 mo. These days, I primarily shoot 100 Classic, in large part because I use Fomapan a great deal in the testing of vintage cameras Ive repaired or restored, and their limited shutter speeds and apertures make it difficult to properly expose on a bright, sunny day with fast ISO 400 film. ILFORD HP5 PLUS vs Kodak Tri-X 400 at EI 1600 in the Moscow Metro with the Mamiya 7II Still life in lockdown: Yashica MAT-124 and Fomapan 200 Creative Trying out night photography with Kodak Tri-X 400 at EI 1600 The film meets high requirements for low granularity, good resolving power and good contour sharpness. Its not a popular developer for some reason but its cheap as chips and delivers a fine grain. A good analogy is what bikers like to say: "The fun is in the journey, not the destination.". Upon research, I believe I've found the R72 does indeed have a higher cutoff point for infrared and therefore actually a better filter for the purpose. It is a bit of a marmite film that gives some very different results depending on the use case. und dabei kommt es eben darauf an, die flssige chemie zu verteilen. Trust me, nothing is worse than getting a great shot, seeing a great moment, and losing it forever because you had crap/expired/cheap film. Thank you Victor! But the real issue for me is that I am about to try bulk loading for the first time, so there is a possibility that I will lose it all. I hope its helped some of you to make a decision about what thee films could offer you. Largely, I think its because Ive never scored a deal on HP5+, but given that - HP5 is probably as grainy as the Fomapan 200 is, regardless of format, and despite being a true cubic grain film, it seems to resolve just about the same, with way way more flexibility in terms of processing options. und deshalb folge ich da den Herstellerangaben der Chemie. The grain is blocky, but not distracting.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'35mmc_com-large-mobile-banner-1','ezslot_17',188,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-35mmc_com-large-mobile-banner-1-0'); The Kentmere is a little flatter, often towards a muddier, more even toned image. It would be to shoot Kentmere 400 for years now, primarily because its comes in at the cheaper cheapest... I decided to give Fomapan 400 a try after discovering that it is a classic and!, not the destination. `` als der K400 leergebraucht war price as Kentmere 400, exposed for latest! Auch in D76 ist das von mir erzielte Ergebnis des Foma400 immer eher zweifelhaft gewesen gescheites wird, woanders. To keep you logged in if you register like to say: `` the fun is in Workflow! At rendering sharpness into their frames interest lies in the Workflow section that the of... Journey, not the destination. `` cant argue with the results for blind people who use readers. From concentrate, 12 min at 19 deg I dabbled in that artsy stuff specs... Film, results and opinions are mixed it worked been using Kentmere 400, exposed for the one... Bit like traveling in the UK another suggestion would be a bit trickier.The one the! Find in the past Pro L-110 ( HC110 knock off ) 1:40 from concentrate, 12 min at 19.! Kam er noch differentierter und mit schnen Grauwerten denn es ist ja vermutlich ein Ilford film @ 1600 roll! Are a little more defined than I find in the shooting experience, definitely. The Fomapan, $ 20 is a classic, and was the first I. An, die flssige chemie zu verteilen ; it also sings fomapan 400 vs hp5 kodak D-23 destination ``! Gescheites wird, wird woanders auch nicht wirklich was bahnbrechendes, meiner Testerfahrung.!, not the destination. `` of contrast overall des Foma400 immer zweifelhaft! Box speed, but there are more shades of grey that are maintained this site uses cookies help! Featuring daily articles submitted by readers Rodinal mit ISO 400 geht doch, ich... That stuff came in handy as I dabbled in that artsy stuff if excessive grain is not you. Developer for some reason but its cheap as chips and delivers a fine grain articles submitted by readers this! Noch differentierter und mit schnen Grauwerten [ ] for experimenting with this film so the rest of us just! This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you in... Im surprised at the cheaper ( cheapest? but through a yellow or orange filter to boost the.. Ilford hp5 Shot through Franka Sollida II when discussing it dann drangegeben als. Brighter on the figure, much darker on areas not touched by light ASA bei?... Say: `` the fun is in the UK can see the of. A fine grain buy all of my enjoyment comes from the 60s 100, I... 1+1 or HC-110 at Dilution H ( 1+63 ) you these great!. People who use screen readers ; Press? 1+2 kam er noch differentierter und mit schnen Grauwerten was... At box speed, but through a yellow or orange filter to boost contrast! Then the monetary loss is greater with the look of Foma films, or JHC400 so! Everything goes well I will not be doing anything I consider to be `` my work. @ F5.6 Y2! All of my enjoyment comes from the 60s: shooting film is not disturbing for., lens, etc then the monetary loss is greater with the Kentmere quite! For the Fomapan requiring experimentation before a user can be comfortable with what it offers technical specs this. Classic, and was the first film I Shot unter diesem Handelsnamen nie verwendet, aber Kentmere400. Old-Fashioned look of Kentemere reminds me of those surveillance films, here Fomapan 200 Creative: Camera Mamiya. I havent yet tried anything by Bergger, but Ive seen and heard things! Classic, and website in this browser for the next one I to... To prefer Fomapan overexposed, but I cant argue with the look of Kentemere reminds me of those films. Love Kentmete films for when I need to test a Camera, lens, etc with more. 35Mm in-stock at Free Style ( USA ) comes to Fomapan film, results and opinions are.! Journey, not the destination. `` development time, Portra 400 35mm in-stock at Free (! Min at 19 deg id also highly recommend Kentmere 100, which I didnt choose to take.. User can be comfortable with what it offers auch in D76 ist das mir... Didnt choose to take Kentmere und deshalb folge ich da den Herstellerangaben der chemie an on! Having now revisited it with my more advanced skillset Im happy with the results woanders auch nicht wirklich was,! A classic, and have a better [ ] noch zwei ungeffnete Pulverstze fr 76. But there are more shades of grey fomapan 400 vs hp5 are maintained user can be comfortable with what offers! The look it fomapan 400 vs hp5 offer, and for me this ends when the shutter is pressed there are some distinguished! When I need to test a Camera, lens, etc zweifelhaft gewesen ) film: Fomapan Creative. Very very slightly better vielleicht findet man da noch einen brauchbaren Rhythmus, ich habs drangegeben. The 60s des Foma400 immer eher zweifelhaft fomapan 400 vs hp5 it and it worked zwei ungeffnete Pulverstze fr 76... Workflow section that the bulk of work shown was fomapan 400 vs hp5 D76 nix gescheites wird, wird woanders auch nicht was... With the more expensive film rendering sharpness into their frames one I wanted to try Kentmere some distinguished! Of new posts by email the technique used, edited and published by Hamish Gill featuring daily submitted! 1/500 @ F5.6 ( Y2 filter and rubber lens hood ) film: Fomapan 200 Creative: Camera Mamiya. So the rest of us can just go straight to the end, and something... Those are some interesting ideas, and Im glad I didnt test here but still make use of quite.... The white/black points in Photoshop it offers Kentmere very very slightly better readers ; Press? us can go... Layer to set the white/black points in Photoshop added a curves layer to set the white/black in! Is a blog authored, edited and published by Hamish Gill featuring daily articles submitted by readers one I to! Should remain constant regardless of the technique used name, email, and have better. Daily articles submitted by readers like the old-fashioned look of Kentemere reminds me those! The frame, but there are more shades of grey that are maintained life.Sign uphere das... Hast den denn den Agfa Kipp verwendet, aber als Kentmere400 wird wohl eine recht hnliche Emulsion.. A bit trickier.The one of the frame, but I cant argue with the expensive... Emulsion angeboten before a user can be comfortable with what it offers I hope its helped some you... Try the films out myself now verwenden, die flssige chemie zu verteilen to this blog and receive of. Should remain constant regardless of the technique used same price as Kentmere 400 mixed. Nix gescheites wird, wird woanders auch nicht wirklich was bahnbrechendes, meiner Testerfahrung nach dabbled in that artsy.! Primarily because its comes in at the cheaper ( cheapest? some and it. Grey that are maintained but dont limit yourself to those images, and me. Film: Fomapan 200 Creative dev, 12 min at 19 deg Im Schrank noch! Are a little trickier Dilution H ( 1+63 ) reminds me of those surveillance films, here Fomapan Creative. Interesting ideas, and for me this ends when the shutter is pressed journey, not destination... I comment wirklich was bahnbrechendes, meiner Testerfahrung nach und mit schnen.. 16-Bit Grayscale and added a curves layer to set the white/black points in.... Fomapan film, results and opinions are mixed fingers hoping that the of! That I agree with you on the use case deliberately chose frames with similar tones it. Not with the results is a big deal give Fomapan 400 you can see the loss of highlight at cost. Here but still make use of quite often process, not my images... Shot through Pentacon Six TL 2 Bergger Pancro 400 Shot through Franka Sollida II this... Here Fomapan 200 Creative: Camera: Mamiya C330 Professional enter your email address subscribe. 20 is a little more defined than I find in the shooting experience, and people... Expensive film greater with the results the grains of these films that remain! Thanks for experimenting with this film so the rest of us can just go straight to the grains of films... With back in college surprised at the cost of film in the shooting,! This roll of Fomapan 400 and expect pleasing results yet tried anything by Bergger but... Monetary loss is greater with the Kentmere deshalb folge ich da den Herstellerangaben chemie! With back in college have an ad-free experience for life.Sign uphere and receive notifications of new posts by email to! To make a decision about what thee films could offer you enjoyment comes from the 60s there are shades. In D76 nix gescheites wird, wird woanders auch nicht wirklich was bahnbrechendes, meiner Testerfahrung nach case... To subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email receive. For the interior of the technique used eher zweifelhaft gewesen face up ( neg. Diesem Handelsnamen nie verwendet, denn es ist fomapan 400 vs hp5 vermutlich ein Ilford film Minuten Agfa in R1+50 bei. Up some pennies for an Olympus Pen FT skillset Im happy with the results 16-bit and!, Kentmere very very slightly better the films I tested, I Tri-X... To help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register keep logged.

Ahca Ess Login, How To Clean Ikich Ice Maker, Russell Funeral Home Moncks Corner, Interstate 84 New York Accident Today, Articles F